| | | Hillsdale wins the toss, defers to the second half |
| | | Mercyhurst will receive; Hillsdale will defend the north goal. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc30 | HC ball on HC30. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 55 yards to the MC15, 6-Theo Hall return 41 yards to the HC44 (53-Brian Thompson;2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for loss of 1 yard to the HC45 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 2-11 | at Hc45 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 9-Frank Ziegler. |
| Mc | 3-11 | at Hc45 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 13-Josh Szeluga for 21 yards to the HC24, 1ST DOWN MC (19-Lance Smith). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc24 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for loss of 3 yards to the HC27 (2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Mc | 2-13 | at Hc27 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 14 yards to the HC13, 1ST DOWN MC (25-Alex Wojcik;19-Lance Smith). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc13 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 22-Richard Stokes for 9 yards to the HC4, out-of-bounds (93-Evan Brown). |
| Mc | 2-1 | at Hc04 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for no gain to the HC4 (75-Mark Yassay;47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 3-1 | at Hc04 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 80-Brandon Hill. |
| Mc | 4-1 | at Hc04 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 3 yards to the HC1, 1ST DOWN MC (2R-Cody Henderson;47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 1-G | at Hc01 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 13-Josh Szeluga for 1 yard to the HC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:08. |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 7, Hillsdale College 0 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 44 yards, TOP 04:00 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 36 yards to the HC34, 45-Zach Rausch return 0 yards to the HC34, fumble by 45-Zach Rausch recovered by MC 36-P J. O'Connor at HC14. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc14 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 11:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc14 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 80-Brandon Hill for 14 yards to the HC0, 1ST DOWN MC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:54. |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 14, Hillsdale College 0 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 14 yards, TOP 00:06 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 37 yards to the HC33, 45-Zach Rausch return 2 yards to the HC35, out-of-bounds. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc35 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 10:51. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc35 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the HC36 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-9 | at Hc36 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 26-Aaron Waldie for 20 yards to the MC44, 1ST DOWN HC (2-Adam Brown;38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 9 yards to the MC35 (27-C. Gleisner;38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-1 | at Mc35 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 7 yards to the MC28, 1ST DOWN HC (38-Tim Herbener;2-Adam Brown). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc28 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 1 yard to the MC27 (6-Theo Hall;38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-9 | at Mc27 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 15 yards to the MC12, 1ST DOWN HC (20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc12 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 1 yard to the MC13 (8-Dave Stallard). |
| Hc | 2-11 | at Mc13 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 9 yards to the MC4 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Mc04 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 06:30. |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Mc04 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 26-Aaron Waldie for 4 yards to the MC0, 1ST DOWN HC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:24. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Mercyhurst College 14, Hillsdale College 7 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 65 yards, TOP 04:27 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 55 yards to the MC15, 6-Theo Hall return 19 yards to the MC34 (44-A. Yarbrough). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc34 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 06:17. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc34 | 19-Joe Laffey rush for 5 yards to the MC39 (99-Drew Berube). |
| Mc | 2-5 | at Mc39 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 80-Brandon Hill. |
| Mc | 3-5 | at Mc39 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 3-Aaron Haynes for 6 yards to the MC45, 1ST DOWN MC (19-Lance Smith). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc45 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 6 yards to the HC49 (75-Mark Yassay). |
| Mc | 2-4 | at Hc49 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 3-Aaron Haynes. |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Hc49 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 04:15. |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Hc49 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 13-Josh Szeluga for 9 yards to the HC40, 1ST DOWN MC, out-of-bounds. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc40 | 19-Joe Laffey rush for 2 yards to the HC38 (44-A. Yarbrough;4-Mat Szula). |
| Mc | 2-8 | at Hc38 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 4 yards to the HC34 (91-Schuyler File). |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Hc34 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 80-Brandon Hill. |
| Mc | 4-4 | at Hc34 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 02:35. |
| Mc | 4-4 | at Hc34 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass intercepted by 47-Tom Korte at the HC40, 47-Tom Korte return 0 yards to the HC40. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 32 yards, TOP 03:49 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc40 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 02:28. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc40 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the HC41 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-9 | at Hc41 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 3-9 | at Hc41 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 22 yards to the MC37, 1ST DOWN HC (20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc37 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 4 yards to the MC33 (27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 2-6 | at Mc33 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 4 yards to the MC29 (67-Bryan Kelly). |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Mc29 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 27 yards to the MC2, 1ST DOWN HC (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 1-G | at Mc02 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the MC1 (8-Dave Stallard). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 59 yards, TOP 03:08 |
| | | Mercyhurst College 14, Hillsdale College 7 |
| Hc | 2-G | at Mc01 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Hc | 2-G | at Mc01 | 85-Billy Kanitz rush for no gain to the MC1 (91-Zac Wild;67-Bryan Kelly). |
| Hc | 3-G | at Mc01 | 85-Billy Kanitz rush for 1 yard to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:20. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 14, Mercyhurst College 14 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 60 yards, TOP 03:08 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 58 yards to the MC12, 22-Richard Stokes return 32 yards to the MC44, out-of-bounds (2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 14:12. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 80-Brandon Hill (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc44 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline (47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 3-4 | at Mc50 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 13-Josh Szeluga for 12 yards to the HC38, PENALTY MC illegal motion 5 yards to the MC45, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 3-9 | at Mc45 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 80-Brandon Hill for 11 yards to the HC44, 1ST DOWN MC (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 80-Brandon Hill for 25 yards to the HC19, 1ST DOWN MC (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc19 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 3 yards to the HC16 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Hc16 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 11:00. |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Hc16 | 19-Joe Laffey pass incomplete to 3-Aaron Haynes. |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Hc16 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 46-Andrew Bukta for 5 yards to the HC11, out-of-bounds (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 4-2 | at Hc11 | 96-Chris Ryan field goal attempt from 27 MISSED - wide left, spot at HC20, clock 09:59. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 45 yards, TOP 06:53 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 11 yards to the HC31, 1ST DOWN HC (20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc31 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 8 yards to the HC39 (10-Craig Moone;27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 2-2 | at Hc39 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 56 yards to the MC5, 1ST DOWN HC (2-Adam Brown). |
| Hc | 1-G | at Mc05 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 3 yards to the MC2 (67-Bryan Kelly;27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 2-G | at Mc02 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 1 yard to the MC3 (27-C. Gleisner;20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 3-G | at Mc03 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:19. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 21, Mercyhurst College 14 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 80 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 44 yards to the MC26, 18-Dustin Schwab return 18 yards to the MC44 (85-Billy Kanitz). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 07:11. |
| | | Injury timeout. Mercyhurst trainers attend to player. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for no gain to the MC44 (44-A. Yarbrough;93-Evan Brown). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc44 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 13-Josh Szeluga. |
| Mc | 3-10 | at Mc44 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 13-Josh Szeluga. |
| Mc | 4-10 | at Mc44 | 98-Alex Emerich punt 33 yards to the HC23, fair catch by 1-Nick Gurica. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc23 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 06:05. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc23 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 10 yards to the HC33, 1ST DOWN HC (6-Theo Hall). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc33 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the HC36 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-7 | at Hc36 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 9 yards to the HC45, 1ST DOWN HC, out-of-bounds (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Hc45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 3-10 | at Hc45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 6-Theo Hall at the MC31, 6-Theo Hall return 33 yards to the HC36 (22-Vinnie Panizzi). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 22 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc36 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 04:22. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc36 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 46-Andrew Bukta for 16 yards to the HC20, 1ST DOWN MC (93-Evan Brown). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for no gain to the HC20 (91-Schuyler File). |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Hc20 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 13-Josh Szeluga, PENALTY HC pass interference (25-Alex Wojcik) 15 yards to the HC5, 1ST DOWN MC, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Hc05 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 5 yards to the HC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:21. |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 21, Mercyhurst College 21 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 40 yards to the HC30, out-of-bounds, PENALTY MC illegal kicking (96-Chris Ryan) 5 yards to the MC25, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Mc25 | MC ball on MC25. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 36 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 31 yards to the HC44, 1-Nick Gurica return 0 yards to the HC44 (18-Dustin Schwab;31-Donovan Dula). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 03:15. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for 25 yards to the MC31, 1ST DOWN HC (27-C. Gleisner;10-Craig Moone). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc31 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the MC28 (27-C. Gleisner;6-Theo Hall). |
| Hc | 2-7 | at Mc28 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 4 yards to the MC24 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 3-3 | at Mc24 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 80-Matt Patillo for 9 yards to the MC15, 1ST DOWN HC (10-Craig Moone). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc15 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 12 yards to the MC3, 1ST DOWN HC (23-J. Mccormick;10-Craig Moone). |
| Hc | 1-G | at Mc03 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:51. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 28, Mercyhurst College 21 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 56 yards, TOP 02:24 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 57 yards to the MC13, 22-Richard Stokes return -3 yards to the MC10 (5-Mike Blanchard). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc10 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 00:43. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc10 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 22-Richard Stokes for loss of 2 yards to the MC8 (59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Mc | 2-12 | at Mc08 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 00:36. |
| Mc | 2-12 | at Mc08 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 7 yards to the MC15 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 3-5 | at Mc15 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| | | Hillsdale College 28, Mercyhurst College 21 |
| Mc | 3-5 | at Mc15 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, MC ball on MC30. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 39 yards to the HC31, 1-Nick Gurica return 11 yards to the HC42, out-of-bounds (47-D. Marshall). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc42 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 14:54. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc42 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 26-Aaron Waldie for 6 yards to the HC48 (6-Theo Hall;5-Aaron Parks). |
| Hc | 2-4 | at Hc48 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush to the HC48, fumble forced by 38-Tim Herbener, fumble by 22-Vinnie Panizzi recovered by HC 22-Vinnie Panizzi at HC49. |
| Hc | 3-3 | at Hc49 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 7 yards to the MC44, 1ST DOWN HC (27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Mc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie, QB hurry by 93-Stewart Myers. |
| Hc | 3-10 | at Mc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 3-A.J. Kegg. |
| Hc | 4-10 | at Mc44 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 27 yards to the MC17, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc17 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 12:33. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc17 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 64 yards to the HC19, 1ST DOWN MC (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc19 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 4 yards to the HC15 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Mc | 2-6 | at Hc15 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 13-Josh Szeluga (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 3-6 | at Hc15 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 3 yards to the HC12 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Mc | 4-3 | at Hc12 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 9-Frank Ziegler for 12 yards to the HC0, 1ST DOWN MC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:35. |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kick attempt failed. |
| | | Hillsdale College 28, Mercyhurst College 27 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 83 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 49 yards to the HC21, 1-Nick Gurica return 23 yards to the HC44 (18-Dustin Schwab). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 10:28. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds (27-C. Gleisner;38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-4 | at Hc50 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 5 yards to the MC45, 1ST DOWN HC (67-Bryan Kelly). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc45 | 15-Mark Nicolet sacked for loss of 1 yard to the MC46 (5-Aaron Parks;38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-11 | at Mc46 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 10-Craig Moone at the MC28, 10-Craig Moone return 20 yards to the MC48 (5-Mike Blanchard). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 10 yards, TOP 01:28 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc48 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 09:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc48 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass intercepted by 11-Josh Hutchison at the HC16, 11-Josh Hutchison return 0 yards to the HC16. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc16 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 08:53. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc16 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 7 yards to the HC23 (27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 2-3 | at Hc23 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the HC25 (27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 3-1 | at Hc25 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the HC27, 1ST DOWN HC (91-Zac Wild). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc27 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for loss of 2 yards to the HC25 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Hc25 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 3 yards to the HC28 (8-Dave Stallard). |
| Hc | 3-9 | at Hc28 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 28 yards to the MC44, 1ST DOWN HC (23-J. Mccormick). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc44 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 19 yards to the MC25, 1ST DOWN HC, out-of-bounds (6-Theo Hall). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc25 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the MC24 (10-Craig Moone). |
| Hc | 2-9 | at Mc24 | 3-A.J. Kegg rush for 3 yards to the MC21 (55-Fred Hale). |
| Hc | 3-6 | at Mc21 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 3-A.J. Kegg. |
| Hc | 4-6 | at Mc21 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 15 yards to the MC6, 1ST DOWN HC (10-Craig Moone;8-Dave Stallard). |
| Hc | 1-G | at Mc06 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 3 yards to the MC3 (91-Zac Wild). |
| Hc | 2-G | at Mc03 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the MC2 (38-Tim Herbener). |
| Hc | 3-G | at Mc02 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the MC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:00. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 35, Mercyhurst College 27 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 49 yards to the MC21, 6-Theo Hall return to the MC35 (53-Brian Thompson;94-Kam Mueller), PENALTY HC offside 5 yards to the HC25, NO PLAY. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 50 yards to the MC25, out-of-bounds, PENALTY HC illegal kicking (97-Mark Petro) 5 yards to the HC20, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 84 yards, TOP 06:53 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 49 yards to the MC31, 6-Theo Hall return 44 yards to the HC25, out-of-bounds. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 02:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | MC ball on HC25. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 3 yards to the HC22 (59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Hc22 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 26-Max Khuri (2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Mc | 3-7 | at Hc22 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 9 yards to the HC13, 1ST DOWN MC (99-Drew Berube). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 12 yards, TOP 03:34 |
| | | Hillsdale College 35, Mercyhurst College 27 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc13 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc13 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 3-Aaron Haynes (25-Alex Wojcik), PENALTY HC pass interference (25-Alex Wojcik) 11 yards to the HC2, 1ST DOWN MC, NO PLAY. |
| Mc | 1-G | at Hc02 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 1 yard to the HC1 (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 2-G | at Hc01 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for no gain to the HC1 (59-Austin Niemiec;2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Mc | 3-G | at Hc01 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 1 yard to the HC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:26. |
| | | 12-Mitch Phillis pass attempt failed. |
| | | Hillsdale College 35, Mercyhurst College 33 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 25 yards, TOP 03:34 |
| | | 96-Chris Ryan kickoff 27 yards to the HC43, fair catch by 19-Lance Smith, PENALTY MC offside 5 yards to the HC48, 1st and 10, HC ball on HC48. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc48 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 13:19, HC ball on HC48. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc48 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 23-J. Mccormick at the MC29, 23-J. Mccormick return 23 yards to the HC48, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc48 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 13:12, MC ball on HC48. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc48 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 13 yards to the HC35, 1ST DOWN MC (4-Mat Szula). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc35 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 3 yards to the HC32 (4-Mat Szula). |
| Mc | 2-7 | at Hc32 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 22-Richard Stokes for loss of 8 yards to the HC40 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Mc | 3-15 | at Hc40 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 11:13. |
| Mc | 3-15 | at Hc40 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 9-Frank Ziegler for 13 yards to the HC27 (7-Jared Kell). |
| Mc | 4-2 | at Hc27 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 9-Frank Ziegler for 11 yards to the HC16, 1ST DOWN MC (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Hc16 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 1 yard to the HC15 (47-Tom Korte;4-Mat Szula). |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Hc15 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 09:10. |
| Mc | 2-9 | at Hc15 | 12-Mitch Phillis sacked for loss of 10 yards to the HC25 (99-Drew Berube). |
| Mc | 3-19 | at Hc25 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 26-Max Khuri to the HC20, fumble forced by TM-TEAM, fumble by 26-Max Khuri recovered by HC 11-Josh Hutchison at HC18. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 30 yards, TOP 04:58 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc18 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 08:14. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc18 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 2 yards to the HC16 (67-Bryan Kelly). |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Hc16 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the HC18 (67-Bryan Kelly;8-Dave Stallard). |
| Hc | 3-10 | at Hc18 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 6 yards to the HC24 (67-Bryan Kelly;27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 4-4 | at Hc24 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 52 yards to the MC24, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 02:18 |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc24 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 05:56. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc24 | 22-Richard Stokes rush for 4 yards to the MC28 (59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Mc | 2-6 | at Mc28 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass complete to 26-Max Khuri for 4 yards to the MC32. |
| Mc | 3-2 | at Mc32 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 13-Josh Szeluga. |
| Mc | 4-2 | at Mc32 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete (99-Drew Berube). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc32 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 04:27. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc32 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 3 yards to the MC29 (20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 2-7 | at Mc29 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 12 yards to the MC17, 1ST DOWN HC (27-C. Gleisner). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc17 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the MC15 (91-Zac Wild). |
| Hc | 2-8 | at Mc15 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the MC12 (20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 3-5 | at Mc12 | 1-Nick Gurica rush for 12 yards to the MC0, 1ST DOWN HC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:49. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Hillsdale College 42, Mercyhurst College 33 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 32 yards, TOP 02:38 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 46 yards to the MC24, 6-Theo Hall return 16 yards to the MC40 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc40 | MERCYHURST COLLEGE drive start at 01:44. |
| Mc | 1-10 | at Mc40 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 3-Aaron Haynes. |
| Mc | 2-10 | at Mc40 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass incomplete to 9-Frank Ziegler (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Mc | 3-10 | at Mc40 | Timeout Mercyhurst College, clock 01:32. |
| Mc | 3-10 | at Mc40 | 12-Mitch Phillis pass intercepted by 47-Tom Korte at the 50 yardline, 47-Tom Korte return 11 yards to the MC39 (13-Josh Szeluga). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:23 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc39 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 01:21. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Mc39 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 7 yards to the MC32 (38-Tim Herbener;20-Shawn Daniels). |
| Hc | 2-3 | at Mc32 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for no gain to the MC32 (91-Zac Wild). |
| Hc | 3-3 | at Mc32 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Hillsdale College 42, Mercyhurst College 33 |