| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv35 | HC ball on HC30. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 57 yards to the SV13, 19-Matt Black return 14 yards to the SV27 (5-Mike Blanchard;86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv27 | 6-Mike Meade rush for 73 yards to the HC0, 1ST DOWN SV, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:41. |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 7, Hillsdale College 0 |
| Sv | 1-G | at Sv35 | SV ball on SV30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 73 yards, TOP 00:19 |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kickoff 55 yards to the HC15, 26-Aaron Waldie return 19 yards to the HC34 (29-Jeff Delamater). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc34 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 14:35. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc34 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 21-M.Lancaster at the HC42, 21-M.Lancaster return 3 yards to the HC39 (43-A. Hesselink). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc39 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 14:28. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc39 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 14 yards to the HC25, 1ST DOWN SV (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc25 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 9 yards to the HC16 (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 2-1 | at Hc16 | 10-Dan Stiefel sacked for loss of 9 yards to the HC25 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 3-10 | at Hc25 | PENALTY SV false start (60-Josh Gibbs) 5 yards to the HC30. |
| Sv | 3-15 | at Hc30 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for 9 yards to the HC21 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 4-6 | at Hc21 | 82-Jeremy Burr field goal attempt from 38 MISSED - wide left, spot at HC21, clock 12:36. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:23 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc21 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 80-Matt Patillo. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Hc21 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 6 yards to the HC27, out-of-bounds. |
| Hc | 3-4 | at Hc27 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 4-4 | at Hc27 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 50 yards to the SV23, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv23 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 12:05. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv23 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 4 yards to the SV27 (44-A. Yarbrough). |
| Sv | 2-6 | at Sv27 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 3 yards to the SV30 (19-Lance Smith). |
| Sv | 3-3 | at Sv30 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 86-Kevin Kelch for 35 yards to the HC35, 1ST DOWN SV (4-Mat Szula). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc35 | 30-Toby Goetz rush for 5 yards to the HC30 (25-Alex Wojcik;86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 2-5 | at Hc30 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 86-Kevin Kelch to the HC20, fumble forced by 47-Tom Korte, fumble by 86-Kevin Kelch recovered by SV 60-Josh Gibbs at HC20, 1ST DOWN SV. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 87-Joe Dougherty rush for loss of 2 yards to the HC22 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Hc22 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 5 yards to the HC17 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 3-7 | at Hc17 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the HC17 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 4-7 | at Hc17 | 82-Jeremy Burr field goal attempt from 38 GOOD, clock 08:03. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 10, Hillsdale College 0 |
| Sv | 1-G | at Sv35 | SV ball on SV30. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 60 yards, TOP 04:02 |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kickoff 45 yards to the HC25, 5-Mike Blanchard return 13 yards to the HC38 (46-Tom Brady). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc38 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 07:58. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc38 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 7 yards to the HC45 (21-M.Lancaster;8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 2-3 | at Hc45 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 5 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN HC (33-Jason Kelly). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc50 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 5 yards to the SV45 (33-Jason Kelly). |
| Hc | 2-5 | at Sv45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 32-Brett Lark. |
| Hc | 3-5 | at Sv45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 4-5 | at Sv45 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 37 yards to the SV8, fair catch by 19-Matt Black. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 01:50 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv08 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 06:08. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv08 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush to the SV3, fumble by 22-Brandon Emeott recovered by SV 22-Brandon Emeott at SV5. |
| Sv | 2-13 | at Sv05 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 1 yard to the SV4 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 3-14 | at Sv04 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 96 yards to the HC0, 1ST DOWN SV, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:39. |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 17, Hillsdale College 0 |
| Sv | 1-G | at Sv35 | SV ball on SV30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 92 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kickoff 48 yards to the HC22, 26-Aaron Waldie return 16 yards to the HC38 (25-Andrew Filipek). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc38 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 04:32. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc38 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 26-Aaron Waldie for 29 yards to the SV33, 1ST DOWN HC (33-Jason Kelly;8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv33 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 5 yards to the SV28 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 2-5 | at Sv28 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the SV25 (19-Matt Black). |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Sv25 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 12 yards to the SV13, 1ST DOWN HC (8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv13 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the SV11 (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 2-8 | at Sv11 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 3-8 | at Sv11 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 4-8 | at Sv11 | 97-Mark Petro field goal attempt from 28 MISSED - wide left, spot at SV20, clock 02:34. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 51 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv20 | 30-Toby Goetz rush to the SV25, fumble forced by 7-Jared Kell, fumble by 30-Toby Goetz recovered by HC 2R-Cody Henderson at SV34. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 14 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv34 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 02:27. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv34 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 02:27. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv34 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Sv34 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 3-A.J. Kegg. |
| Hc | 3-10 | at Sv34 | 15-Mark Nicolet sacked for loss of 7 yards to the SV41 (95-Brad Bush). |
| Hc | 4-17 | at Sv41 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 27 yards to the SV14, fair catch by 19-Matt Black. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 7 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv14 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 01:26. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv14 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 2 yards to the SV16 (86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 2-8 | at Sv16 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 6-Mike Meade for 4 yards to the SV20 (18-P. Schoening). |
| Sv | 3-4 | at Sv20 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 86-Kevin Kelch. |
| Sv | 4-4 | at Sv20 | 11-Kurtis Fournier punt 49 yards to the HC31, fair catch by 1-Nick Gurica. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc31 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 00:06. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc31 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 11 yards to the HC42, 1ST DOWN HC (33-Jason Kelly). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 11 yards, TOP 02:39 |
| | | Saginaw Valley 17, Hillsdale College 0 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc42 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc42 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 13 yards to the SV45, 1ST DOWN HC (47-Derek Volmering;2-Mark Miller). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv45 | 15-Mark Nicolet sacked for loss of 2 yards to the SV47 (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Sv47 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 1 yard to the SV48 (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 3-13 | at Sv48 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 80-Matt Patillo for 11 yards to the SV37 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 4-2 | at Sv37 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 12:31. |
| Hc | 4-2 | at Sv37 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 32 yards, TOP 02:39 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv37 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 12:27. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv37 | 87-Joe Dougherty rush for 14 yards to the HC49, 1ST DOWN SV (86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc49 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 10 yards to the HC39, 1ST DOWN SV (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc39 | 85-Galen Stone rush to the HC29, fumble forced by 19-Lance Smith, fumble by 85-Galen Stone recovered by HC 2R-Cody Henderson at HC26. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 37 yards, TOP 00:38 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc26 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 11:49. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc26 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Hc26 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for no gain to the HC26 (8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 3-10 | at Hc26 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 13 yards to the HC39, 1ST DOWN HC (8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc39 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 80-Matt Patillo for 16 yards to the SV45, 1ST DOWN HC (48-Ryan Murphy). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 8-Kyle Rowley at the SV37, 8-Kyle Rowley return 0 yards to the SV37. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 29 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv37 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 10:16. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv37 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 99-Ric Cottengim (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Sv37 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 3 yards to the SV40 (82-Eric Schweller). |
| Sv | 3-7 | at Sv40 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 87-Joe Dougherty. |
| Sv | 4-7 | at Sv40 | 11-Kurtis Fournier punt 35 yards to the HC25, out-of-bounds, PENALTY HC roughing the kicker declined. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:49 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 09:27. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | HC ball on HC30. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc30 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 1 yard to the HC31 (95-Brad Bush). |
| Hc | 2-9 | at Hc31 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 6 yards to the HC37 (51-Kerk Summers;47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 3-3 | at Hc37 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 4 yards to the HC33 (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 4-7 | at Hc33 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 41 yards to the SV26, 19-Matt Black return 2 yards to the SV28 (85-Billy Kanitz). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv28 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 07:29. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv28 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 2 yards to the SV30 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 2-8 | at Sv30 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 2 yards to the SV28 (99-Drew Berube). |
| Sv | 3-10 | at Sv28 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 4 yards to the SV32 (4-Mat Szula). |
| Sv | 4-6 | at Sv32 | 11-Kurtis Fournier punt 44 yards to the HC24, 1-Nick Gurica return 4 yards to the HC28 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc28 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 05:26. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc28 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for 5 yards to the HC33 (8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 2-5 | at Hc33 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 80-Matt Patillo for 11 yards to the HC44, 1ST DOWN HC (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 4 yards to the HC48 (48-Ryan Murphy). |
| Hc | 2-6 | at Hc48 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 80-Matt Patillo. |
| Hc | 3-6 | at Hc48 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 3-A.J. Kegg. |
| Hc | 4-6 | at Hc48 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 49 yards to the SV3, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv03 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 03:21. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv03 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 99-Ric Cottengim. |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Sv03 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 22-Brandon Emeott. |
| Sv | 3-10 | at Sv03 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 14 yards to the SV17, 1ST DOWN SV (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv17 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 1 yard to the SV16 (59-Austin Niemiec;86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 2-11 | at Sv16 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for 8 yards to the SV24 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 3-3 | at Sv24 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 5 yards to the SV19 (44-A. Yarbrough). |
| Sv | 4-8 | at Sv19 | Timeout Saginaw Valley, clock 01:46. |
| Sv | 4-8 | at Sv19 | 11-Kurtis Fournier punt 37 yards to the HC44, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 16 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 01:34. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 2-10 | at Hc44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 18 yards to the SV38, 1ST DOWN HC (8-Kyle Rowley;19-Matt Black). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv38 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 8 yards to the SV30, out-of-bounds. |
| Hc | 2-2 | at Sv30 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Sv30 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 4-2 | at Sv30 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 7 yards to the SV23, 1ST DOWN HC (2-Mark Miller). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv23 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 9 yards to the SV14, out-of-bounds. |
| Hc | 2-1 | at Sv14 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete. |
| Hc | 3-1 | at Sv14 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the SV12, 1ST DOWN HC (95-Brad Bush). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv12 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 8 yards to the SV4 (21-M.Lancaster). |
| Hc | 2-2 | at Sv04 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Sv04 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 26-Aaron Waldie for 4 yards to the SV0, 1ST DOWN HC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:19. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 17, Hillsdale College 7 |
| Hc | 1-G | at Hc35 | HC ball on HC30. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 56 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 0 yards to the HC30, 85-Galen Stone return -23 yards to the SV47 (2R-Cody Henderson;86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv47 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 00:14. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv47 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete. |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Sv47 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 8 yards to the HC45, out-of-bounds. |
| Sv | 3-2 | at Hc45 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 87-Joe Dougherty for 36 yards to the HC9, 1ST DOWN SV. |
| Sv | 1-G | at Hc09 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 44 yards, TOP 00:14 |
| | | Saginaw Valley 17, Hillsdale College 7 |
| Sv | 1-G | at Hc09 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sv | 1-G | at Hc09 | SV ball on SV30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 44 yards, TOP 00:14 |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kickoff 51 yards to the HC19, 26-Aaron Waldie return 18 yards to the HC37 (97-Pete Oskvarek). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc37 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 14:53. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc37 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 4 yards to the HC41 (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 2-6 | at Hc41 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 9 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN HC (2-Mark Miller). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc50 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for 12 yards to the SV38, 1ST DOWN HC (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv38 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass intercepted by 47-Derek Volmering at the SV28, 47-Derek Volmering return 8 yards to the SV36 (63-Dan Stapf). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv36 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 13:52. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv36 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 8 yards to the SV44 (7-Jared Kell). |
| Sv | 2-2 | at Sv44 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 2 yards to the SV46, 1ST DOWN SV (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv46 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 10 yards to the HC44, 1ST DOWN SV (19-Lance Smith). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 9 yards to the HC35 (19-Lance Smith;55-Marcellus Wade). |
| Sv | 2-1 | at Hc35 | 1st and 10. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc35 | 87-Joe Dougherty rush for 5 yards to the HC30 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 2-5 | at Hc30 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush to the HC1, fumble forced by 11-Josh Hutchison, fumble by 22-Brandon Emeott recovered by HC TM-TEAM at HC0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 64 yards, TOP 02:12 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc20 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 11:40. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 10 yards to the HC30, 1ST DOWN HC (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc30 | PENALTY SV personal foul (47-Derek Volmering) 15 yards to the HC45, 1ST DOWN HC. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc45 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for loss of 2 yards to the HC43 (34-John Jacobs). |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Hc43 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 4 yards to the HC47 (34-John Jacobs). |
| Hc | 3-8 | at Hc47 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 4-8 | at Hc47 | 6-Matt Vanover punt 33 yards to the SV20, fair catch by 19-Matt Black. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 27 yards, TOP 00:51 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv20 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 10:49. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv20 | 87-Joe Dougherty rush for 11 yards to the SV31 (99-Drew Berube), PENALTY SV holding (99-Ric Cottengim) 9 yards to the SV22. |
| Sv | 1-8 | at Sv22 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 17-Andrew Beaver for 3 yards to the SV25 (11-Josh Hutchison;59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Sv | 2-5 | at Sv25 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 86-Kevin Kelch for 3 yards to the SV28 (59-Austin Niemiec;2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Sv | 3-2 | at Sv28 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 3 yards to the SV31, 1ST DOWN SV (18-P. Schoening). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv31 | 1st and 10. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv31 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the SV31 (4-Mat Szula;25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Sv31 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 19 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SV (4-Mat Szula). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv50 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 9 yards to the HC41 (4-Mat Szula;47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 2-1 | at Hc41 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 9 yards to the HC32, 1ST DOWN SV (44-A. Yarbrough). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc32 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 85-Galen Stone for 4 yards to the HC28 (2R-Cody Henderson). |
| Sv | 2-6 | at Hc28 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 5 yards to the HC23 (18-P. Schoening). |
| Sv | 3-1 | at Hc23 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 3 yards to the HC20, 1ST DOWN SV (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for 20 yards to the HC0, 1ST DOWN SV, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:25. |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 24, Hillsdale College 7 |
| Sv | 1-G | at Sv35 | SV ball on SV30. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 80 yards, TOP 04:24 |
| | | 82-Jeremy Burr kickoff 51 yards to the HC19, 26-Aaron Waldie return 18 yards to the HC37 (39-Sutton Richmond). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc37 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 06:13. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc37 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 5 yards to the HC42 (54-Josh Miller). |
| Hc | 2-5 | at Hc42 | PENALTY SV personal foul (34-John Jacobs) 15 yards to the SV43, 1ST DOWN HC. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv43 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 7 yards to the SV36 (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 2-3 | at Sv36 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for loss of 8 yards to the SV44 (95-Brad Bush), PENALTY HC holding 0 yards to the SV44. |
| Hc | 2-11 | at Sv44 | 2nd and 12. |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Sv44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete. |
| Hc | 3-12 | at Sv44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 19 yards to the SV25, 1ST DOWN HC (19-Matt Black). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv25 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the SV23 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 2-8 | at Sv23 | 3-A.J. Kegg rush for 3 yards to the SV20 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 3-5 | at Sv20 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi for 2 yards to the SV18 (51-Kerk Summers;47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 4-3 | at Sv18 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the SV15, 1ST DOWN HC (2-Mark Miller). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv15 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 3 yards to the SV12 (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 2-7 | at Sv12 | 32-Brett Lark rush for 4 yards to the SV8 (33-Jason Kelly). |
| Hc | 3-3 | at Sv08 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 80-Matt Patillo. |
| Hc | 4-3 | at Sv08 | 97-Mark Petro field goal attempt from 24 GOOD, clock 01:09, PENALTY SV roughing the kicker 4 yards to the SV4, 1ST DOWN HC, NO PLAY. |
| Hc | 1-G | at Sv04 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 4 yards to the SV0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:04. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 24, Hillsdale College 14 |
| Hc | 1-G | at Hc35 | HC ball on HC30. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 63 yards, TOP 05:09 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 55 yards to the SV15, 19-Matt Black return 19 yards to the SV34 (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv34 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 00:53. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv34 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 2 yards to the SV32 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Sv32 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 85-Galen Stone. |
| Sv | 3-12 | at Sv32 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 13 yards to the SV45, 1ST DOWN SV. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv45 | 85-Galen Stone rush for 6 yards to the HC49 (4-Mat Szula). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 17 yards, TOP 07:58 |
| | | Saginaw Valley 24, Hillsdale College 14 |
| Sv | 2-4 | at Hc49 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sv | 2-4 | at Hc49 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 5 yards to the HC44, 1ST DOWN SV (94-Kam Mueller). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc44 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 2 yards to the HC46 (94-Kam Mueller). |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Hc46 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 11 yards to the HC35 (4-Mat Szula;59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Sv | 3-1 | at Hc35 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 6 yards to the HC29, 1ST DOWN SV (19-Lance Smith). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc29 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for 10 yards to the HC19, 1ST DOWN SV (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc19 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 6-Mike Meade for loss of 2 yards to the HC21 (7-Jared Kell). |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Hc21 | 85-Galen Stone rush for 6 yards to the HC15 (47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 3-6 | at Hc15 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 99-Ric Cottengim (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Sv | 4-6 | at Hc15 | 82-Jeremy Burr field goal attempt from 32 MISSED - wide right, spot at HC20, clock 12:21. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 51 yards, TOP 07:58 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc20 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 2 yards to the HC22 (34-John Jacobs). |
| Hc | 2-8 | at Hc22 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 80-Matt Patillo for 23 yards to the HC45, 1ST DOWN HC (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc45 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 3 yards to the HC48 (52-Bryan Klobucar). |
| Hc | 2-7 | at Hc48 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 5 yards to the SV47 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 3-2 | at Sv47 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 1 yard to the SV46 (95-Brad Bush). |
| Hc | 4-1 | at Sv46 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush for 2 yards to the SV44, 1ST DOWN HC (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv44 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 12 yards to the SV32, 1ST DOWN HC (21-M.Lancaster). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv32 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 2-Derek Nelson for 13 yards to the SV19, 1ST DOWN HC (19-Matt Black). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv19 | Timeout Saginaw Valley, clock 08:50. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv19 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 5 yards to the SV14 (47-Derek Volmering). |
| Hc | 2-5 | at Sv14 | PENALTY HC false start (80-Matt Patillo) 6 yards to the SV20. |
| Hc | 2-11 | at Sv20 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie. |
| Hc | 3-11 | at Sv20 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 3-A.J. Kegg for 20 yards to the SV0, 1ST DOWN HC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:55. |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kick attempt good. |
| | | Saginaw Valley 24, Hillsdale College 21 |
| Hc | 1-G | at Hc35 | HC ball on HC30. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 80 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | 97-Mark Petro kickoff 65 yards to the SV5, 99-Ric Cottengim return 10 yards to the SV15, out-of-bounds. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv15 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 07:51. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv15 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 6-Mike Meade (11-Josh Hutchison). |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Sv15 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 1 yard to the SV16 (4-Mat Szula;47-Tom Korte). |
| Sv | 3-9 | at Sv16 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 99-Ric Cottengim for 18 yards to the SV34, 1ST DOWN SV (55-Marcellus Wade). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv34 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 4 yards to the SV38 (4-Mat Szula). |
| Sv | 2-6 | at Sv38 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 6-Mike Meade for 23 yards to the HC39, 1ST DOWN SV (19-Lance Smith), PENALTY HC pass interference declined. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc39 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 99-Ric Cottengim (94-Kam Mueller). |
| Sv | 2-10 | at Hc39 | 85-Galen Stone rush for 1 yard to the HC38 (4-Mat Szula;25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 3-9 | at Hc38 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to 6-Mike Meade, PENALTY SV intentional grounding (10-Dan Stiefel) 16 yards to the SV46. |
| Sv | 4-25 | at Sv46 | 4th and 25. |
| Sv | 4-25 | at Sv46 | 11-Kurtis Fournier punt 43 yards to the HC11, fair catch by 1-Nick Gurica. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 31 yards, TOP 02:31 |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc11 | HILLSDALE COLLEGE drive start at 05:20. |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc11 | 22-Vinnie Panizzi rush for 14 yards to the HC25, 1ST DOWN HC (8-Kyle Rowley). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc25 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 13 yards to the HC38, 1ST DOWN HC (20-M.McClenney). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Hc38 | 15-Mark Nicolet sacked for loss of 2 yards to the HC36 (37-Mike LeVand). |
| Hc | 2-12 | at Hc36 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 22-Vinnie Panizzi. |
| Hc | 3-12 | at Hc36 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass complete to 1-Nick Gurica for 17 yards to the SV47, 1ST DOWN HC (19-Matt Black). |
| Hc | 1-10 | at Sv47 | 5-Mike Blanchard rush for loss of 4 yards to the HC49 (33-Jason Kelly). |
| Hc | 2-14 | at Hc49 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 26-Aaron Waldie (20-M.McClenney). |
| Hc | 3-14 | at Hc49 | 15-Mark Nicolet rush to the SV45, fumble forced by 47-Derek Volmering, fumble by 15-Mark Nicolet recovered by HC 2-Derek Nelson at SV42. |
| Hc | 4-5 | at Sv42 | 15-Mark Nicolet pass incomplete to 1-Nick Gurica. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 47 yards, TOP 02:57 |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv42 | SAGINAW VALLEY drive start at 02:23. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Sv42 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for 2 yards to the SV44 (47-Tom Korte;86-Eric Weber). |
| Sv | 2-8 | at Sv44 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 02:18. |
| Sv | 2-8 | at Sv44 | 10-Dan Stiefel rush for 8 yards to the HC48, 1ST DOWN SV (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc48 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 02:08. |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc48 | 22-Brandon Emeott rush for loss of 2 yards to the 50 yardline (69-Jordan Knudsen;59-Austin Niemiec). |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Sv50 | Timeout Hillsdale College, clock 02:02. |
| Sv | 2-12 | at Sv50 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 22-Brandon Emeott for 2 yards to the HC48 (7-Jared Kell). |
| Sv | 3-10 | at Hc48 | 10-Dan Stiefel pass complete to 7-Steve Brander for 12 yards to the HC36, 1ST DOWN SV (25-Alex Wojcik). |
| Sv | 1-10 | at Hc36 | TM-TEAM rush for loss of 3 yards to the HC39. |
| Sv | 2-13 | at Hc39 | TM-TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the HC40. |
| Sv | 3-14 | at Hc40 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:23 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Saginaw Valley 24, Hillsdale College 21 |