| Date | Location | Result | |
| May 06, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Ashland 3, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| May 06, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 3, Ashland 2 | Box score |
| May 5, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 2, Ashland 1 | Box score |
| May 5, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 2, Ashland 1 | Box score |
| May 01, 2012 | Ypsilanti, Mich. | Eastern Michigan 5, Hillsdale College 4 | Box score |
| Apr 29, 2012 | Columbus, Ohio | Ohio Dominican 2, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Apr 29, 2012 | Columbus, Ohio | Ohio Dominican 4, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| Apr 28, 2012 | Columbus, Ohio | Ohio Dominican 4, Hillsdale College 3 | Box score |
| Apr 28, 2012 | Columbus, Ohio | Hillsdale College 2, Ohio Dominican 1 | Box score |
| Apr 22, 2012 | Tiffin, Ohio | Hillsdale College 4, Tiffin University 3 | Box score |
| Apr 22, 2012 | Tiffin, Ohio | Tiffin University 5, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2012 | Tiffin, Ohio | Tiffin University 2, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2012 | Tiffin, Ohio | Tiffin University 8, Hillsdale College 5 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Wayne State 17, Hillsdale College 9 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 11, Wayne State 5 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Northwood 5, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 12, Northwood 10 | Box score |
| Apr 14, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Northwood 13, Hillsdale College 9 | Box score |
| Apr 14, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 18, Northwood 17 | Box score |
| Apr 10, 2012 | Allendale, Mich. | Grand Valley State 12, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Apr 10, 2012 | Allendale, Mich. | Grand Valley State 4, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 07, 2012 | Findlay, Ohio | Findlay 2, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Apr 07, 2012 | Findlay, Ohio | Hillsdale College 3, Findlay 1 | Box score |
| Apr 06, 2012 | Findlay, Ohio | Hillsdale College 5, Findlay 3 | Box score |
| Apr 06, 2012 | Findlay, Ohio | Findlay 3, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Apr 03, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Hillsdale College 5, Grand Valley State 2 | Box score |
| Apr 03, 2012 | Hillsdale, Mich. | Grand Valley State 6, Hillsdale College 4 | Box score |
| Apr 01, 2012 | Painesville, Ohio | Lake Erie College 4, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Apr 01, 2012 | Painesville, Ohio | Lake Erie College 3, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Mar 31, 2012 | Painesville, Ohio | Lake Erie College 8, Hillsdale College 6 | Box score |
| Mar 31, 2012 | Painesville, Ohio | Lake Erie College 11, Hillsdale College 6 | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2012 | Detroit, Mich. | Hillsdale College 5, Wayne State 4 | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2012 | Detroit, Mich. | Wayne State 5, Hillsdale College 4 | Box score |
| Mar 25, 2012 | Univ. Center, MI | Saginaw Valley 3, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| Mar 25, 2012 | Univ. Center, MI | Saginaw Valley 6, Hillsdale College 5 | Box score |
| Mar 24, 2012 | Univ. Center, MI | Saginaw Valley 4, Hillsdale College 3 | Box score |
| Mar 24, 2012 | Univ. Center, MI | Saginaw Valley 5, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |
| Mar 21, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Florida Christian 11, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Southeastern 5, Hillsdale College 4 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Mt. Vernon 18, Hillsdale College 9 | Box score |
| Mar 19, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Florida Christian 8, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| Mar 17, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Hillsdale College 3, Alderson-Broaddus 0 | Box score |
| Mar 17, 2012 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Alderson-Broaddus 14, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| Mar 11, 2012 | Louisville, KY | Bellarmine 12, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Mar 10, 2012 | Louisville, KY | Bellarmine 5, Hillsdale College 4 | Box score |
| Mar 10, 2012 | Louisville, KY | Bellarmine 8, Hillsdale College 1 | Box score |
| Mar 05, 2012 | Owensboro, KY | Kentucky Wesleyan 5, Hillsdale College 2 | Box score |
| Mar 04, 2012 | Owensboro, KY | Hillsdale College 4, Kentucky Wesleyan 2 | Box score |
| Mar 04, 2012 | Owensboro, KY | Kentucky Wesleyan 1, Hillsdale College 0 | Box score |